![[Picture]](../images/aglarule.gif) The Oganessian et al. collaborations all report on one event in which 248 Cm + 48 Ca is used to produce a decay chain commencing with 292116, followed by well-reproduced a-decay sequence assigned to the otherwise unknown 288114 and 284112 and terminating in spontaneous fission of previously unknown 280 Ds. The decay energies and lifetimes of three events for 288 114 are internally redundant, but no link to recognized nuclei occurs. 24896Cm + 4820Ca → 292116Uuh + 4 n The Dubna collaborations have performed careful, high-quality studies whose acknowledgment as discoveries is unfortunately not yet warranted because of unsecured connection to known descendents or of no observed elemental signatures (such as well-resolved X-ray energies). Yu. Ts. Oganessian, V. K. Utyonkov, Yu. V. Lobanov, F. Sh. Abdullin, A. N. Polyakov, I. V. Shirokovsky, Yu. S. Tsyganov, G. G. Gulbekian, S. L. Bogomolov, B. N. Gikal, A. N. Mezentsev, S. Iliev, V. G. Subbotin, A. M. Sukhov, O. V. Ivanov, G. V. Buklanov, K. Subotic, M. G. Itkis, K. J. Moody, J. F. Wild, N. J. Stoyer, M. A. Stoyer, R. W. Lougheed, C. A. Laue, Ye. A. Karelin, A. N. Tatarinov. Observation of the decay of 262 116 , Phys. Rev. C 63, 011301/1011301/2 (2001). Yu. Ts. Oganessian, V. K. Utyonkov, K. J. Moody. Synthesis of 292 116 in the 248 Cm + 48 Ca reaction , Phys. Atom. Nucl. 64, 13491355 (2001). ![[Picture]](../images/aglarule.gif) For completeness, we note the Ninov et al. Berkeley collaboration report V. Ninov, K. E. Gregorich, W. Loveland, A. Ghiorso, D. C. Hoffman, D. M. Lee, H. Nitsche, W. J. Swiatecki, U. W. Kirbach, C. A. Laue, J. L. Adams, J. B. Patin, D. A. Shaughnessy, D. A. Strellis, P. A. Wilk. Observation of superheavy nuclei produced in the reaction of Kr-86 with Pb-208, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 11041107 (1999). on the reaction 86 Kr + 208 Pb leading to the observation of three chains terminating in 269 Sg and passing through observed intermediate 289 116. Retraction of results appears in: V. Ninov, K. E. Gregorich, W. Loveland, A. Ghiorso, D. C. Hoffman, D. M. Lee, H. Nitsche, W. J. Swiatecki, U. W. Kirbach, C. A. Laue, J. L. Adams, J. B. Patin, D. A. Shaughnessy, D. A. Strellis, P. A. Wilk. Editorial note: Observation of superheavy nuclei produced in the reaction of 86 Kr with 208 Pb [Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 1104 (1999)], Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 039901 (2002). |